The S&P 500 remains to be considerably overpriced

Welcome again. Each twist and switch from the White Home brings a brand new rally or sell-off within the S&P 500. However is the market lacking the larger image?

Regardless of indicators of a slowing US economic system, Donald Trump’s tariff plans and stultifying uncertainty, Wall Road analysts nonetheless count on the primary US inventory index to finish 2025 slightly below 6,000 on common. Which means the market tasks the S&P 500 will rise by not less than 5 per cent between now and December 31.

So this week, I’ll define the case for why the market is incorrect, and why the S&P 500 is extra prone to finish this yr considerably under its present degree of 5,525.

Finish-year inventory market forecasts are in the end underpinned by traders’ annual financial outlook and their evaluation of structural drivers, comparable to synthetic intelligence and US exceptionalism.

For 2025, analysts basically count on the S&P 500 degree to be broadly unchanged on final yr. That could be a notable markdown from the previous two years of consecutive annual progress above 20 per cent. However is it nonetheless too optimistic?

Let’s start with the financial fundamentals. Final month, I argued that America was heading for a recession. (This was based mostly on financial weak point coming into Trump’s second time period, the uncertainty of his insurance policies, and the potential of some import duties being carried out.) I admire that this isn’t Wall Road’s view, but.

Analysts are extra targeted on precise tariff bulletins. Certainly, since “liberation day”, consensus progress forecasts for 2025 have fallen and chances for a recession within the subsequent 12 months have risen to 45 per cent. Most count on the US efficient tariff price (pre-substitution results) to settle round 10 to twenty per cent this yr. It’s at present estimated at round 28 per cent, having began 2025 near 2.5 per cent.

These forecasts appear cheap: notably larger tariffs than final yr and slower progress, even when there is no such thing as a recession. Nevertheless, the market remains to be pricing extra optimistically than that.

“The information derived from risk assets doesn’t even suggest markets reckon a mild slowdown will take shape this year,” mentioned Daniel Von Ahlen, a senior macro strategist at TS Lombard, utilising a easy regression mannequin to estimate US progress forecasts from asset costs.

Expectations for company earnings this yr stay too excessive. It’s simpler for Wall Road to make purchase and promote selections based mostly on perceived risk-on or risk-off information objects. Judging their affect on corporations’ backside strains can take longer.

“Typically earnings estimates decline during even mild recessions,” mentioned Peter Berezin, chief world strategist at BCA Analysis. “But the market currently assumes nearer 10 per cent earnings growth over the next 12 months. That’s off last year’s peak profit margins no less.”

Analysts could also be too optimistic in regards to the means of corporations to move by way of any tariff prices to shoppers. The sectors that import probably the most — industrials, supplies and shopper discretionary — even have restricted pricing energy, notes BCA Analysis’s US fairness technique group.

Assuming corporations received’t be capable to elevate costs considerably, it reveals Trump’s tariffs decreasing S&P 500 web revenue margins by 2.2 share factors. That may translate to a 19.2 per cent decline in S&P 500 earnings per share, all else equal (based mostly on tariff charges at 10 per cent for all international locations, Chinese language import duties returning to their pre-retaliation price of 54 per cent, and metal, aluminium and car-specific levies at 25 per cent.)

For measure, Goldman Sachs estimates that every 5 share level rise within the US tariff price leads S&P 500 EPS to fall roughly between 1 to 2 per cent.

No matter one’s tariff outlook, consensus forecasts for EPS to develop notably in 2025 seem at odds with the present financial atmosphere: excessive uncertainty, weak shopper and investor confidence, and elevated import duties. (Scheduled vessels into the Port of Los Angeles are anticipated to drop considerably yr on yr in two weeks’ time.)

Earnings revisions are coming in quickly now. The variety of earnings downgrades by analysts for 2025 is mockingly at recessionary ranges, although the precise magnitudes of the downgrades stay comparatively much less vital. As earnings projections come down, costs will observe, as analysts calibrate valuations.

For measure, the ahead price-to-earnings ratio (how a lot traders are keen to pay for every greenback of future earnings) is at present round 19. Within the 5 years previous to the pandemic, it was nearer to 17. And in all recessions since 1980, it has averaged round 10.

Utilizing Goldman Sachs’ S&P 500 sensitivity matrix, a nonetheless modest forecast for EPS to develop by 3 per cent this yr and ahead P/E ratios to return to only above their pre-pandemic common would put the index nearer to 4,550.

After all, it’s potential for the S&P 500 to dodge such a hefty fall if structural components present shopping for impetus.

However first, the AI narrative is hitting roadblocks. DeepSeek’s low-cost mannequin launch in China put the highlight on the billions being spent by US tech companies on AI capital. Trump’s commerce bulletins — together with deliberate duties on Asian tech manufacturing hubs and chip export restrictions — have added additional stress.

“We’re still waiting for a ‘killer app’ that justifies the heavy capex taking place. The low barriers to building large language models also raise further questions over the revenue [the Magnificent Seven] can generate”, explains Hugh Grieves, a fund supervisor at Premier Miton Traders. “[They] are also only slowly assessing how tariffs impact their earnings”.

The inventory costs of the Magnificent Seven tech companies have dropped substantively since Trump’s inauguration. However analysts are unclear on what’s being priced in. The businesses account for one-third of the S&P 500’s market capitalisation. (Additionally they skew web revenue margin estimates for the entire inventory market upward.) So promoting them is a straightforward option to reduce danger publicity because the information whipsaws.

Nonetheless, their ahead P/E multiples stay above pre-pandemic ranges (individually and collectively). Costs may drop additional as their profitability is re-evaluated, each by way of tariffs and AI hype.

Second, US exceptionalism. For years America has attracted capital by advantage of its deep liquidity, stability and the safe-haven standing of its belongings. This enabled the S&P 500 to develop past financial fundamentals.

However the narrative is weakening. In March, respondents to Financial institution of America’s Fund Supervisor survey slashed their US fairness holdings by the most on document. Tariffs weigh disproportionately on America. Its corporations are the best beneficiaries of the “Made in Asia” mannequin, notes Matt King, founding father of Satori Insights. (Retaliatory measures will harm US companies too.)

Coverage upheaval, radical uncertainty, rising monetary stability dangers and assaults on impartial financial establishments (such because the US Federal Reserve most lately) make the US a much less dependable place to park capital.

“The US has gone from the ‘cleanest dirty shirt’ to being one of the ugliest and yet still most expensive item cluttering the investment wardrobe,” says King. “Even after this year’s correction, US equities retain a significant exceptionalism premium trading on forward P/Es 50 per cent higher than non-US equities.”

This exposes America to additional capital flight, relying on the attractiveness of alternatives overseas and Trump’s actions. Paradoxically, if the president’s time period continues because it has began, the US can be extra reliant on improved financial fundamentals to construct shopping for momentum.

The S&P 500 has oscillated down round 10 per cent from its February peak. However the newsflow makes it troublesome to know what has and hasn’t been priced in.

The fixed churn of coverage bulletins, exemptions, postponements and denials imply traders re-price every day the place they take into account danger to be relative to the day earlier than. This then shifts the goalposts for judging progress and profitability forecasts.

For all of the noise, nevertheless, the market nonetheless appears positioned for a hopeful end result. Shares aren’t even priced proper now for a light downturn. “For the S&P 500 to rise to where the consensus is now, Trump would need to immediately roll back tariffs”, reckons Berezin.

Certain, latest climbdowns recommend the president will be turned considerably. However by how a lot? And when? If most traders fairly count on tariff charges to ultimately settle not less than a number of multiples larger underneath Trump than the place they began 2025, they’re but to completely value that in, together with the lingering affect of financial uncertainty.

Wall Road’s earnings and progress projections have additional to fall. As they do, markets can also additional scrutinise the AI and US exceptionalism narratives. That’s why I concern the S&P 500 will finish the yr not with a 5 deal with, not to mention a 6 — however with a 4.

Ship your rebuttals, reflections and end-year S&P 500 forecasts to freelunch@ft.com or on X @tejparikh90.

Meals for thought

Planning a social media detox? A brand new research of Fb and Instagram deactivations earlier than the 2020 US election discovered enhancements in measures of customers’ happiness, melancholy and anxiousness.