A younger supporter of bullfighting joins an indication in help of bullfighting exterior Mexico Metropolis’s Congress the place lawmakers are anticipated to debate its continuation in Mexico Metropolis on Tuesday.
Ginnette Riquelme/AP
cover caption
toggle caption
Ginnette Riquelme/AP
MEXICO CITY — Mexico Metropolis lawmakers on Tuesday voted overwhelmingly to ban violent bullfighting, triggering outrage from aficionados and celebration from animal rights advocates.
The laws, accepted by a 61-1 vote, prohibits the killing of bulls and the usage of sharp objects that might injure the animals. It additionally units closing dates on how lengthy bulls could possibly be within the ring, all a part of an initiative dubbed “bullfighting without violence.”
The choice sparked indignant protests from bullfighting supporters and matadors, a few of whom tried to breach a police barricade on the native Congress. Some carried indicators that learn “Being a fan of la fiesta brava (bullfighting) is not a crime, it’s a point of pride.”
In the meantime, Animal rights protesters and lawmakers pushing the invoice celebrated, strolling out onto the steps of Congress surrounded by police in riot gear, pumping their fists and carrying stuffed bull dolls.
“It was either this or nothing,” mentioned Sofía Morín, an animal rights activist with the group Tradition With out Torture, Mexico With out Bullfighting, main the initiative to vary the legal guidelines. “We prefer this because, without a doubt, it’s a huge step in protecting animals.”
Mexico Metropolis Mayor Clara Brugada of the ruling Morena get together echoed activists saying the choice would flip the Mexican capital into a spot “that respects the rights of animals.
Tuesday’s vote appeared to be an attempt to broker a compromise between two warring sides of the debate after years of back-and-forth about the practice.
Bullfighting has long been considered a tradition and a pastime in Latin American nations, but has come under criticism for animal cruelty because bulls are often killed at the end of the fight. Animal rights groups say that approximately 180,000 bulls are killed every year in bullfighting worldwide.
The custom, which has lengthy drawn huge crowds to arenas throughout Mexico, was dealt a blow when a decide in Mexico Metropolis banned the follow in June 2022, shutting down an area that has been billed because the world’s largest bullfighting ring. The decide dominated that bullfights violated metropolis residents’ rights to a wholesome setting free from violence.
Whereas animal rights advocates celebrated it as a victory, and a step towards ending the bloody custom, bullfighters mentioned it dealt an financial blow to town. The Nationwide Affiliation of Breeders of Preventing Bulls in Mexico says bullfighting generates 80,000 direct jobs, and 146,000 oblique jobs throughout the nation. Total, the trade generates roughly $400 million a yr.
That was the priority for a lot of within the crowd protesting the tip of the violent fights, whereas others like Juan Pablo Pimienta screamed via a megaphone “it’s an activity where the fighting bull dies in a bullring. That’s its nature. … It is a beast.”
In 2023, Mexico’s Supreme Court docket overturned the ban with out rationalization, permitting bullfighting arenas to be flooded as soon as once more with followers of the so-called “fiesta brava.”
On Tuesday, in a speech earlier than town’s congress, Inexperienced Celebration lawmaker Jesús Sesma acknowledged that the choice would anger a section of town’s inhabitants.
“To those families who feel frustrated today, we’re here to say that no one lost their job,” he mentioned. “There was a middle ground to continue with these bullfighting spectacles, but now without violence.”
