Vice President Harris makes remarks on July 17 at a screening of a documentary about Hamas’ sexual violence throughout the Oct. 7 assault on Israel.
Anna Moneymaker/Getty Pictures
cover caption
toggle caption
Anna Moneymaker/Getty Pictures
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is assembly on Thursday with President Biden and later — individually — with Vice President Harris because the nine-month-long battle in Gaza continues to stay a political legal responsibility for Democrats heading right into a presidential election.
Netanyahu’s go to comes at a important second in American politics: with 4 months to the election, the White Home is keen to safe a cease-fire deal to finish Israel’s battle with Hamas, which started final October with the militant group’s assault on Israel that killed 1,200 folks.
Israel’s response has killed 39,000 Palestinians, a big proportion of them civilians, in accordance with the Ministry of Well being in Gaza. A possible deal to finish the battle will undoubtedly be a spotlight of Biden and Harris’ conferences with Israel’s chief.
Harris, who’s now the seemingly Democratic presidential nominee, inherits this battle as she makes an attempt to keep up a fragile balancing act in a race the place one misplaced phrase on the battle can value her help in key states that Democrats have to maintain the White Home.
She is sustaining the administration’s help of Israel and attempting to not alienate supporters of the Jewish state, who make up a key Democratic constituency. However she can be expressing sympathy for Palestinian civilians killed within the battle and attempting to win again a number of the younger, progressive, Black and Brown voters whom Biden alienated together with his response to the battle.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu shakes fingers with staunchly pro-Israel Sen. John Fetterman, D-Pa., after delivering an tackle to a joint session of Congress on Wednesday.
Allison Bailey/Center East Pictures/AFP/through Getty Pictures
cover caption
toggle caption
Allison Bailey/Center East Pictures/AFP/through Getty Pictures
Harris and the humanitarian value of the battle
As Biden’s vp, Harris has remained in lockstep with the president on coverage, together with his steadfast dedication to the safety of Israel.
“Vice President Harris has gone even a step further in taking a leadership role in condemning the horrific sexual violence that was perpetrated by Hamas,” mentioned Halie Soifer, who served as nationwide safety adviser to Harris within the Senate and now runs the Jewish Democratic Council of America.
“I attended an occasion on the White Home simply final month the place she was the main voice from the White Home in drawing consideration to Hamas’s use of rape as a weapon of battle on that horrific day,” Soifer mentioned.
Although the substance of what Harris has mentioned is just like Biden, when she speaks in regards to the battle, the vp differs in tone, notably in describing what she has known as the “humanitarian catastrophe” in Gaza.
“What we are seeing every day in Gaza is devastating,” Harris mentioned throughout a speech in Selma, Ala., final March. “We have seen reports of families eating leaves or animal feed, women giving birth to malnourished babies with little or no medical care, and children dying from malnutrition and dehydration.”
Activists take part in a pro-Palestinian protest close to the U.S. Capitol on Wednesday. There have been a number of demonstrations close to the Capitol to protest Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s go to to Washington.
Alex Wong/Getty Pictures
cover caption
toggle caption
Alex Wong/Getty Pictures
In each private and non-private, Harris is seen to indicate a larger understanding and empathy for Palestinians, a number of folks informed NPR. And so they say she’s additionally proven larger empathy for protesters demonstrating in opposition to Israel’s navy operation.
She informed The Nation in an interview that younger folks protesting the battle are “showing exactly what the human emotion should be, as a response to Gaza.” Her feedback have caught the eye of voters and international coverage consultants.
“If you look at her public remarks about Gaza as vice president, unlike Biden, she really did manage to convey a much greater empathy and sympathy for the suffering of Palestinians,” mentioned Aaron David Miller, a longtime Center East knowledgeable with the Carnegie Endowment for Worldwide Peace.
A political alternative for Harris
For some Democrats who voted ‘uncommitted’ throughout the presidential primaries as a option to protest Biden’s coverage, Harris’ expressions of empathy has left them open to giving her an opportunity.
“If I had, for example, tried to go to a mosque or Arab community event and urged them to vote for Joe Biden, I would never be invited back. The anger was so deep. And the hurt was so deep — even for me,” mentioned Georgia State Rep. Ruwa Romman, a Palestinian-American.
However Romman says she thinks folks can be open to listening to from Harris and letting her make her case.
Whereas some Democrats wish to see Harris chart a brand new coverage path, consultants say it’s extremely unlikely that if she grew to become president, Harris would break from many years of bipartisan consensus on Israel.
Nonetheless, consultants say she could also be extra open to strike a tone distinct from Biden’s. “She’s a strongly, I would argue, pro-Israeli, moderate, mainstream Democrat,” mentioned Miller.
“But at the same time, she really doesn’t have Biden’s long history with Israel nor any of its leaders. And she’s also from a different generation, which means she’s going to put a greater focus, I think, on human rights, diversity, discrimination.”
Abdullah Hammoud, the mayor of Dearborn, Mich., dwelling to the biggest Arab-American neighborhood within the U.S., voted uncommitted throughout the primaries.
He has mentioned he felt betrayed by the administration, however now says he appears like there’s a chance for Harris to “course correct.” He factors out {that a} majority of Democrats disapproveof the Israeli navy’s actions in Gaza.
“Now, whether hope flourishes or dies, I really believe it’s going to be dependent upon these next crucial weeks and the messages that come forward from Vice President Kamala Harris’s campaign,” Hammoud mentioned. “I think she has a real opportunity.”
Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu and Home Speaker Mike Johnson stroll contained in the Capitol earlier than Netanyahu’s tackle to a joint session of Congress on Wednesday.
Allison Bailey/Center East Pictures/AFP/through Getty Pictures
cover caption
toggle caption
Allison Bailey/Center East Pictures/AFP/through Getty Pictures
Critics of Biden’s Gaza coverage aren’t the one ones watching Harris’ messages within the weeks forward. Democrats are deeply divided on Israel, and Republicans are united in criticizing her. Netanyahu is scheduled to satisfy with former President Donald Trump, the Republican nominee, on Friday, and Harris’ views will virtually definitely come up.
The vp sometimes presides over joint addresses in Congress, however on Wednesday, she was not current for Netanyahu’s remarks. Her group cited a scheduling battle.
However Home speaker Mike Johnson informed Jewish Insider it was a “terrible symbolic gesture” and advised she would “pay a price for it politically.”
