Unlock the Editor’s Digest totally free
Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly publication.
Traders in Ethiopia’s defaulted greenback bond have accused the IMF of exaggerating how a lot debt aid the nation wants, arguing {that a} surge in gold and occasional exports have restored the funds of east Africa’s largest financial system to a sounder footing.
A committee of holders of the $1bn debt stated that the fund was undermining talks to finish a 2023 default after it “significantly undervalued” a rebound in exports since Ethiopia devalued its foreign money towards the greenback final yr, in accordance with an announcement seen by the Monetary Occasions.
The committee accused the fund of making an attempt to “reverse-engineer” debt aid as a part of a $3.4bn bailout and likewise stated it was reserving authorized rights over the debt after it rejected a proposal by Ethiopia to write down down the bond final yr.
The dispute displays one of many largest faultlines to resolving a wave of sovereign defaults from Sri Lanka to Zambia lately, as buyers have more and more criticised how the IMF oversees key debt aid targets. Whereas the fund isn’t immediately concerned in debt restructuring talks between governments and bondholders, its financial forecasts strongly affect negotiations.
The IMF stated final month that “Ethiopia’s debt continues to be unsustainable and in distress”, a view the committee disputes.
The IMF’s projections for Ethiopia “artificially imply a solvency issue which requires Ethiopia to seek greater concessions from its stakeholders in order to meet the IMF’s lending criteria than, in our view, are actually required to achieve debt sustainability”, the committee stated.
The committee, which owns 40 per cent of the Ethiopian bond, contains hedge funds Farallon Capital Administration and VR Capital, individuals acquainted with the matter stated.
The IMF didn’t instantly reply to a request for remark. The fund conditioned final yr’s bailout on the devaluation of Ethiopia’s foreign money, the birr, and is backing different reforms. Kristalina Georgieva, IMF managing director, visited Addis Ababa earlier this month.
In October, the bondholder committee turned down a proposal to chop the debt’s face worth by 18 per cent, after the legacy of a two-year civil battle led Ethiopia to skip curiosity funds in 2023.
Most of Ethiopia’s roughly $30bn exterior debt is owed to multilateral collectors, or particular person nations reminiscent of China, which are seen as much less keen to just accept outright losses. However the IMF’s bailout is requiring debt to be lowered relative to exports.
Throughout Georgieva’s go to, Ahmed Shide, Ethiopia’s finance minister, stated the nation was in “the final stage of negotiations” with its collectors. The fund has stated that the nation is getting nearer to a take care of its bilateral lenders.
After the birr’s peg to the greenback was dropped in July, exports doubled yr on yr to greater than $3bn within the second half of 2024 whereas imports fell barely to $8.6bn over the identical interval, Ethiopia’s central financial institution stated final week.
Espresso exports from Africa’s largest producer rose by 60 per cent to just about $1bn, whereas gold exports surged greater than 700 per cent to $1.3bn.
In an replace final month, IMF employees acknowledged that Ethiopia’s exports can be “slightly stronger” within the close to time period, however added that medium-term projections of exports of products and providers would keep unchanged, at round 9 to 10 per cent of GDP.
The growth in espresso exports adopted a pointy rise in world costs in addition to the foreign money shift, whereas the rise in gold exports has mirrored “previously smuggled production moving to official channels,” it added.
UK and African think-tanks Debt Justice, the Horn Financial and Social Coverage Institute, and Afrodad argued in a latest paper that bondholders might have made returns of a 3rd in the event that they accepted Ethiopia’s so-called ‘haircut’ final yr.
This was primarily based on the idea of buyers shopping for the bonds at their common value of 67 cents on the greenback between 2022 and 2024.
“Bondholders rejected an extremely generous deal. It allowed them to still make a profit and required bilateral creditors to be repaid significantly less for debt sustainability targets to be met,” Tim Jones, coverage director at Debt Justice, stated.
“Bondholders are right to criticise the IMF’s export forecasts for Ethiopia, but it should be because they are extremely optimistic” in contrast with the historic common, Jones added.
The bondholder committee has additionally taken problem with the IMF permitting Ethiopia to barter a mortgage on business phrases to finish the nation’s second largest hydropower dam whereas it’s nonetheless in default on the bond.
At almost $1bn, the dimensions of the IMF’s allowance for the mortgage to be excluded from a bailout restriction on business borrowing is “rare in the context of low-income countries”, and Ethiopia ought to disclose the phrases of the dam financing, the committee stated.
