Individuals are mirrored in a window displaying a poster of then newly appointed Hamas chief Yahya Sinwar within the Palestinian camp of Bourj al-Barajneh on August 08, 2024 in Beirut Lebanon.
Chris McGrath/Getty Photographs
disguise caption
toggle caption
Chris McGrath/Getty Photographs
Individuals are mirrored in a window displaying a poster of then newly appointed Hamas chief Yahya Sinwar within the Palestinian camp of Bourj al-Barajneh on August 08, 2024 in Beirut Lebanon.
Chris McGrath/Getty Photographs
Yahya Sinwar, the chief of Hamas and the person believed to be behind the October seventh assaults towards Israel, is useless.
Israeli officers introduced on Thursday that he was killed by its army in Gaza. Sinwar was Israel’s primary, most needed man in Gaza.
NPR’s Daniel Estrin reported stay from Tel Aviv earlier at present, explaining the state of affairs extra in depth:
“He was calling the shots in this war, he approved a hostage release deal back in November, and he was the man Israel was hoping would approve a cease-fire deal, Israel and many all around the world. He was the man.”
You are studying the Contemplate This text, which unpacks one main information story every day. Subscribe right here to get it delivered to your inbox, and take heed to extra from the Contemplate This podcast.
Sinwar’s legacy
Because the starting of the struggle, Sinwar had eluded seize, probably within the labyrinth of tunnels Hamas constructed underneath Gaza. He was seen as a hardliner inside Hamas and regarded much less more likely to attain a cease-fire take care of Israel.
David Remnick profiled the Hamas chief within the The New Yorker earlier this yr. He spoke to NPR about Sinwar’s ideology — specified by a semi-autobiographical novel Sinwar wrote whereas in an Israeli jail.
“It is certainly nothing having to do with the two-state solution. It is fueled by the absolute conviction that there can be no Israeli state, and there can be no compromise,” Remnick mentioned.
Israel killed Sinwar’s predecessor in addition to the top of Hamas’s army wing – leaving Sinwar because the main determine of the militant group.
A glance to the long run
In an announcement launched Thursday, President Biden referred to as the dying of Hamas chief Yahya Sinwar, “a good day for Israel, for the United States, and for the world,”
To elucidate the bigger implications of Sinwar’s dying for Hamas, the area, and the struggle with Israel, All Issues Thought of host Juana Summers spoke with Daniel Byman, a professor at Georgetown College and a senior fellow on the Middle for Strategic and Worldwide Research, a overseas coverage assume tank.
“It’s a win [for Israel]” Byman mentioned. “They’ve been promoting the idea that he’s a dead man walking since the war’s inception. And Israeli leaders can say to their own people that ‘We now have killed the key architect of October 7th for Hamas.’ He was a hardliner. And if he’s replaced by someone who is more pragmatic or moderate, that could also lead Hamas to be more likely to compromise. But in the past, the killings of major leaders have not led to progress on the cease-fire. And both sides right now seem pretty dug in.”
Sinwar’s dying comes weeks after the Hezbollah chief Hassan Nasrallah was additionally killed by Israel. So what might come subsequent for the militant teams now that a number of distinguished leaders have been killed?
“It’s unclear who is going to be the next leader of Hamas,” Byman mentioned.
“Israel has taken out much of the leadership, which makes it hard to determine what the natural succession is. So it’s going to be a real challenge for Hamas to be able to have a leader who has credibility within the movement and from there have the credibility to be able to make major concessions and otherwise try to move beyond the current conflict.
But a cease-fire still seems like a far off possibility.
“Making a giant leap comparable to a cease-fire that may threat [Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s] political coalition. That leaves an unsure query about home investigations into the October seventh assault inside Israel. That may be a giant soar. And to date no less than, he is been very reluctant to make that.”
This episode was produced by Marc Rivers and Erika Ryan. It was edited by Jeanette Woods, Timbete Ermyas, and James Hider. Our govt producer is Sami Yenigun.
